Home Theories Illusion of validity

Illusion of validity

Reviewed by expert Scientifically proven

Sure, the illusion of validity is a cognitive bias that occurs when people overestimate their ability to predict or control future events based on past experiences or information. This bias can lead individuals to trust their own judgment too much and overlook important factors that could affect their predictions or decision-making. For example, a stock trader who has had a few successful trades may become overconfident in their ability to pick winning stocks and ignore important market trends. The illusion of validity can be detrimental in many areas, including investing, hiring, and decision-making in general.

Table of contents:
  1. What is the Illusion of Validity?
  2. Why Does the Illusion of Validity Occur?
  3. How Can You Avoid the Illusion of Validity?
  4. Conclusion

Sure, here's a blog post about the illusion of validity.

Understanding the Illusion of Validity

As humans, we often believe that our judgments and decisions are completely rational and objective. However, research shows that we are subject to cognitive biases that can influence our perception, judgment, and decision-making process. One such bias is the illusion of validity.

What is the Illusion of Validity?

The illusion of validity is a cognitive bias that occurs when we believe that our judgments or predictions are more accurate than they actually are. This bias arises when we have a great deal of confidence in our ability to make accurate judgments, even when we lack the necessary information or experience.

For example, let's say that you have been given a list of job candidates to evaluate. You review the candidates' resumes and make your initial judgments about their qualifications. You might believe that you have a "gut feeling" about which candidates will be successful in the job, even though you have only limited information about them. This is the illusion of validity at work.

The illusion of validity can lead to overconfidence in our abilities and a tendency to rely on subjective judgments rather than objective criteria. This can have negative consequences in many areas of life, from hiring decisions to investment choices.

Why Does the Illusion of Validity Occur?

The illusion of validity occurs because we are wired to look for patterns and relationships in the information presented to us. We want to make sense of the world around us, and our brains automatically try to find order and meaning in the data we encounter.

However, this tendency can lead us to draw incorrect conclusions or make inaccurate predictions. We may focus too much on certain pieces of information and ignore others that are equally important. This can create a distorted view of reality that leads to poor decision-making.

How Can You Avoid the Illusion of Validity?

The first step in avoiding the illusion of validity is to recognize that it exists. You need to be aware of the potential for bias in your judgments and decisions and be willing to question your assumptions. Here are a few strategies you can use to avoid the illusion of validity:

  1. Use objective criteria: When making judgments or predictions, use objective criteria wherever possible. Focus on measurable, quantifiable data rather than subjective assessments or personal opinions.

  2. Seek out diverse perspectives: To avoid the bias of your own perspective, seek out diverse opinions and input from others. This can help you see your judgments and decisions from a different angle and identify potential biases.

  3. Test your predictions: Instead of relying solely on your intuition or "gut feeling," test your predictions against actual outcomes. This can help you identify areas where your judgment may be biased or inaccurate.

  4. Learn from your mistakes: When you make a mistake or your predictions are inaccurate, use that as an opportunity to learn and improve your decision-making process. Don't be afraid to admit when you are wrong and seek out feedback from others.


The illusion of validity is a common cognitive bias that can lead to inaccurate judgments and decisions. By understanding the bias and implementing strategies to avoid it, you can make better decisions that are grounded in objective data and diverse perspectives. Remember to question your assumptions, seek out input from others, and test your predictions to avoid falling into the trap of the illusion of validity.

A new cognitive bias in your inbox every week

You'll get to learn more about CRO and psychology. You'll be able to take experimenting to a whole new level!

* We send our mails on Monday morning btw.

Will you use psychology for your experimentation process?

Are you curious about how to apply this bias in experimentation? We've got that information available for you!

Join over 452+ users

  • Lifetime access to all biases
  • Filter on metrics, page type, implementation effort
  • More examples and code for experimentation

Choose your subscription!

Pay with Stripe

Lifetime deal PREMIUM

Get access to the search engine, filter page, and future features.

I want this

Lifetime deal

Get access to the search engine and filter page.

I want this

Do you think you know enough about CRO?

Join our monthly mailing to continue learning more and more about CRO and psychology.