Bye-Now effect

Homophones are words which sound the same but have distinctly different meanings (such as “buy” and “bye”, or “wait” and “weight”). The impact of the bye-now effect is that one can be subconsciously exposed to ideas without realizing it, if a writer chooses to deliberately implant words with meaningful homophones (although there is no evidence of this happening to date). So, if we read a note with the word “bye”, we will think of the word “buy” as well, and act accordingly.

Homophones are words which sound the same but have distinctly different meanings (such as “buy” and “bye”, or “wait” and “weight”). The impact of the bye-now effect is that one can be subconsciously exposed to ideas without realizing it, if a writer chooses to deliberately implant words with meaningful homophones (although there is no evidence of this happening to date). So, if we read a note with the word “bye”, we will think of the word “buy” as well, and act accordingly.

What is it?

When we hear the phonetically similar word "bye," the bye-now effect reflects our inclination to think of the word "buy." As a result, the word "buy" primes our behavior, perhaps leading to more spending. Understanding the bye-now effect

The bye-now effect is a relatively novel cognitive bias with two main components. The first, and maybe most evident, is that "buy" and "bye" are homophones. That is, they are words that have various spellings and meanings but are pronounced the same way.

The second element is priming, which exposes customers to one piece of information that alters their response to future information. Homophone priming is the outcome of combining these elements. The brain is unable to disregard the alternative meaning of a homophonic word in this situation.

Why it happens

The bye-now effect happens because it is simple for our brain to mix up linkages and associations when we absorb large volumes of data. Even though "bye" and "buy" are not semantically connected, they are phonetically the same, and the homophones lead us to make improper associations. Words can function as nudges, influencing our behavior. Our brains are extremely sophisticated and do not passively process inputs. The buy-now effect demonstrates that our brains constantly analyze the many connections between words and other known concepts and associations. While these linkages are vital to helping us categorize the massive quantity of data we must digest every day; they may cause us to change our habits.

When we come across a word, it functions as a prod for our brains to map out all possible meanings linked with the term. When we encounter homophones, our brains are driven to think about all phonologically similar words, not just one word's connections. When you hear the word "sight," for example, you might immediately think of "sea." The bye-now effect is thought to arise because humans cannot properly apply homophone suppression when we are faced with a significant cognitive load, according to Derick Davis and Paul Herr, the researchers who initially researched it. That is to say, staying concentrated on a single word or meaning while suppressing any extraneous connections, such as phonologically identical terms, requires work and talent. When we are given a large amount of information, our brains are preoccupied with digesting it and fail to concentrate on each component of the load. As a result, we become distracted by erroneous interpretations.

The buy-now effect, consumer behavior, and marketing

Each diner was invited to read one of two lines before ordering their meal in research that monitored diners at a name-your-own-price restaurant. Diners paid an average of $32 a lunch for the first sentence, "so long." The average price per dinner jumped to $45 when guests pronounced the word "bye-bye" before ordering.

Even when there are no relationships between homophonic words, the bye-now effect causes customers to spend more, according to the findings of this study. Consumers who are distracted or multitasking are also susceptible to the impact, according to other research. When people are bombarded with a lot of information, their brains become overworked, and they take shortcuts to figure out what words mean. As a result, the terms "buy" and "bye" have the same meaning.

Businesses that are creating a brand might benefit from the buy-in now impact. The weight-loss medicine Alli – pronounced "ally" – is one real-world example, meaning that the drug is a helpful companion on the weight-loss journey. Consider the hypothetical corporation Beech & Son, which operates a resort hotel. Despite the absence of proof, the buy-in effect may automatically build favorable associations with holidaying with a brand in this scenario.

Individual effects

Another cognitive bias that affects our financial decision-making is the buy-now effect. The buy-now effect states that when we hear the word "bye," we are more likely to spend more money than if we had not heard it. As a result, the buy-now effect is a bias that leads us to overpay impulsively.

The buy-now effect also highlights how homophones may readily deceive our cognitive processing. Our brains struggle to effectively code each component of the cognitive load when faced with a great quantity of data, and we end up mapping out inefficient relationships to words. We shift our emphasis away from individual word meanings and toward phonologically connected word connections. In truth, the only thing that connects "bye" and "buy" is their phonetic similarity; thus, reading one should not make us think of the other.

Because the buy-now effect is caused by our failure to focus appropriately on the different meanings of words, it affects certain individuals unjustly. According to research, the bye-now effect would have a greater impact on low-skilled readers. Cognitive psychologists Morton Gernsbacher and Mark Haust proposed that memory cells formed in human brains have the power to either trigger or prevent the activation of other memory cells. They claimed that low-skilled readers had less access to previously read material, making them more likely to recall incorrectly activated memory cells. They have a harder time suppressing homophones, and as a result, they are more prone to be confused by homophones.

Systemic effects

As previously said, the bye-now effect may aid in the development of marketing techniques that persuade customers to spend. Because the bye-now effect shows that little, subtle cues may sometimes be enough to affect behavior, homophones are simple strategy businesses can employ to increase spending and consumption. Alternatively, the notion that a single word may influence behavior necessitates extreme caution when selecting a company's name, motto, and branding. A single erroneous word can determine whether or not a campaign is effective.

The restaurant "Sam & Ella's Chicken Palace" in Ohio is an example of a bad name decision. Although we may not recognize it at first, we may be predisposed to think of a phonetically similar term, salmonella, when reading "Sam & Ella." This is not an excellent association to have with a chicken restaurant. While homophone priming may help firms in the buy-effect, word priming might have negative repercussions depending on the homophone.

Furthermore, economic models are frequently predicated on assuming that customers are fully aware of their choices and actions. We aren't entirely aware of what affects our actions since the bye-effect operates unconsciously. This suggests that our models might be off. Biases like the bye-now effect, frequently used to forecast human behavior, show that we need to rethink economic models completely.

Why it is important

Another bias that might influence our financial judgments is the bye-now effect, which causes us to lose sight of reasonable and logical economic decision-making. The presence of a prime wouldn't impact us if we were fully rational thinking when it came to financial decisions because the presence of a prime should have no bearing on how much we feel something is worth.

The bye-now effect and other cognitive biases are crucial since they may be utilized as marketing methods to trick us into overpaying. When something as simple as seeing the word "bye" may impact our shopping decisions, it's evident that we're prone to such tactics. Because the buy-now effect operates unconsciously, we must understand more about it to avoid being persuaded by it.

Although the bye-now effect refers to a circumstance in which the word bye prompts us to consider the related meanings of its homophone, buy, the mechanism that underpins it may be applied to a variety of phonologically similar words and impact a variety of actions. It makes us think about how company names, slogans, and branding are all strategically designed to affect our semantic connections with the brand. Take, for example, the corporate name "Starbucks." The name's association to money might serve as a source of priming.

How to avoid it

The bye-now effect, as previously stated, acts on an unconscious level, making it extremely difficult to detect and prevent. It's hard to stop our brains from thinking about a word's connections since that's the only way we learn what they mean; words would be letters on a page if they didn't work as symbols for anything significant. The problem with the bye-now effect is that it causes people to make improper associations. The words "bye" and "buy" don't have the same meaning — they only sound alike. To avoid the bye-now effect, we must improve our homophone suppression. To avoid the bye-now effect, we can strive to restrict our cognitive load to stay focused since research has revealed that one cause of the impact is handling huge cognitive loads. It might include breaking down material into smaller parts or eliminating distractions when reading an important article. We are less likely to be prepared to make inaccurate connections when we have less information to process at once.

Conclusion:

Although research on how words serve as primes has been around for a while, Derick Davis, a professor of business, and Paul Herr, a professor of marketing, were the first to investigate the bye-now impact in 2014. The academics were aware of the psychological phenomena of priming, a technique in which one stimulus is used to get people to think about another. Davis and Herr were particularly interested in how words may stimulate both semantic and conceptually related notions.

A new cognitive bias every week!

Join our weekly mailing list to continue learning about CRO and psychology.

Sources

Don't believe us? This is where we've found our data.

Only available with an account Register for free, no credit card required
  • Brain iconDirect access to 100+ cognitive biases
  • Brain iconLearn how to apply biases
  • Brain iconAccess to a great community
Create Your Account

Frequently Asked Questions

Do you think you know enough about CRO?

Join our monthly mailing to continue learning more and more about CRO and psychology.